1:35:02
and that is nothing.
1:35:06
It may be nothing to Mr PauIsen,
but it is not nothing to Sarah Tobias.
1:35:11
And I don't beIieve it's nothing to you.
1:35:15
Next Mr Paulsen tried to convince you
1:35:17
that Kenneth Joyce
was the only person there
1:35:20
who knew that Sarah Tobias
was being raped.
1:35:25
The only one.
1:35:29
Now, you watched Kenneth Joyce.
How did he strike you?
1:35:32
Did he seem especially sensitive?
1:35:35
Especially observant?
1:35:37
Did he seem so remarkable
that you immediately thought
1:35:41
"Of course. This man would
notice things other people wouldn't."
1:35:45
Do you believe that Kenneth Joyce saw
something those three men didn't see?
1:35:49
In aII the time that Sarah Tobias
was heId down on that pinbaII machine,
1:35:53
the others didn't know?
1:35:56
Kenneth Joyce confessed to you
1:36:00
that he watched a rape and did nothing.
1:36:03
He told you that everyone in that bar
behaved badly.
1:36:09
And he's right.
1:36:11
But no matter how immoraI it may be,
1:36:15
it is not the crime of criminaI
soIicitation to waIk away from a rape.
1:36:20
It is not the crime of criminaI
soIicitation to siIentIy watch a rape.
1:36:27
But it is the crime
of criminaI soIicitation
1:36:30
to induce, or entreat, or encourage
or persuade another person
1:36:36
to commit a rape.
1:36:38
"Hold her down", "Stick it to her",
"Make her moan".
1:36:43
These three men
did worse than nothing.
1:36:47
They cheered, and they clapped,
1:36:50
and they rooted the others on.
1:36:54
They made sure
that Sarah Tobias was raped,
1:36:59
and raped, and raped.