Murder in the First
prev.
play.
mark.
next.

1:23:00
So help me God.
1:23:01
You may be seated.
1:23:07
Warden Humson, in a book you wrote,
you refer to the convicts as your children.

1:23:12
You liken your job to that of a parent,
providing for their physical needs...

1:23:16
...and molding their character.
1:23:18
Yes, l wrote that.
1:23:19
l have a record of a prisoner
named Johnson...

1:23:22
...who did a total of 500 days
in the lower cells.

1:23:24
The hole, the dungeon.
1:23:26
This was over a ten-year period for such
offenses as not finishing all his food...

1:23:31
...having an extra pair of socks in his cell,
keeping an untidy cell...

1:23:35
...smuggling food from the dining room,
crumbs, in fact, for a pet lizard.

1:23:39
ls this what you mean
''molding character''?

1:23:41
No, no, no.
1:23:43
You're twisting things here.
1:23:45
The isolation cells were simply a tool
of a temporary nature...

1:23:49
...for extreme cases
within the general population.

1:23:54
Moreover, you make it sound like
the prisoner did 1,500 days at one stretch...

1:23:58
...for one infraction.
1:24:01
That's not true.
1:24:03
Prisoners were held...
1:24:05
...for 19 days at a time.
1:24:08
-That's all.
-That's all.

1:24:10
Perhaps you can tell me why Henri Young
did over 1,000 days in the dungeon?

1:24:14
Not 19 days, but 1,000 days...
1:24:17
...in total darkness with only 30 minutes
of daylight a year.

1:24:20
He tried to escape.
1:24:22
You can't compare his offense with that
of a man who smuggled food to a lizard.

1:24:26
Was this the first time a sentence
of three years had been imposed?

1:24:30
lt wasn't a sentence.
1:24:31
lt was an administrative decision
to place him there...

1:24:33
...for an undetermined amount of time.
1:24:36
Why not a time limit? Doesn't that seem
a little bit inhumane? No time limit.

1:24:40
Put simply, no.
1:24:43
While we strive to prevent crime...
1:24:45
...what should we do with a man
who has committed it?

1:24:49
We aim to make him his better self.
1:24:52
His better self.
1:24:54
l'm sure that Henri Young thanks you
for his better self.

1:24:57
lt's a fact you simply put Henri Young
in that dungeon and forgot all about him.


prev.
next.