:03:02
We still can't.
:03:04
Now whenever we run into each other
at lunches or parties...
:03:07
..we find ourselves going over
the evidence one more time.
:03:10
All to understand those five girls,...
:03:14
..who, after all these years,
we can't get out ofour minds.
:03:19
Cecilia, the youngest, was 13.
:03:25
And Lux was 14.
:03:29
Bonnie was 15.
:03:32
Mary was 16.
:03:37
And Therese was 17.
:03:42
No one could understand how Mrs Lisbon
and Mr Lisbon, our math teacher,...
:03:46
..had produced such beautiful creatures.
:03:51
Paul Baldino claimed to have
found Cecilia on her first attempt.
:03:55
Hey, I was the one who found her.
:03:58
I was in the storm sewer under my house.
There's all these tunnels.
:04:02
You could get into anyone's house.
:04:04
When Paul said this, we believed him...
:04:06
..because he was the son
of Sammy "the Shark" Baldino,...
:04:09
..and we knew about his escape tunnel.
:04:11
So I went up, thinking I could see
one of those girls taking a shower!
:04:15
Right!
:04:16
And I walk in...
:04:18
..and I see blood everywhere.
:04:20
So I turned around, went for the stairs
and right back out the tunnel.
:04:25
I had to tell you guys that story.
:04:27
I'll see you guys later, all right?
:04:32
- (woman) I heard there was an accident.
- (woman #2) It was no accident, Joan.
:04:36
Of course the parents are to blame!
:04:39
I heard they found the razor in the toilet...
:04:41
Everyone had an opinion
as to why Cecilia had tried to kill herself.
:04:45
That girl didn't want to die.
She just wanted out of that house.
:04:49
She wanted out
of that decorating scheme.
:04:55
The most popular theory
held Dominic Palazzolo to blame.
:04:59
Dominic was staying with relatives
until his family got settled in New Mexico.